Rustic Mashed Potatoes for Two Recipe | gritsandpinecones.com (2024)

Just wait till you taste one of my favorite side dish recipes, Rustic Mashed Potatoes for Two. Not only is it the best and loaded with flavor, but it is also a one-pan wonder with baby red potatoes topped with a tasty sauce made with tangy cream cheese and fresh chives.

Like my Easy Air Fryer Hasselback Potatoes, this indulgent potato recipe is for two. Of course, if you need to serve more folks, it’s easy to scale both recipes up.

Why you will love this recipe:

1. Like my recipe for Parmesan Smashed Potatoes, it’s quick and easy; you can have this delicious side dish on the table in less than 15 minutes.
2. You don’t have to peel or cut up the potatoes.
3. It only takes minutes to whip the sauce up.

Only six ingredients:

All you need are small red potatoes, cream cheese, butter, fresh chives, kosher salt, and ground black pepper.

How to make it:

Place the spuds in a medium saucepan and add water to cover by at least an inch. Add one teaspoon salt and bring to a boil over medium-high heat. When the water boils, reduce the heat to medium-low and continue to cook for another 10-20 minutes.

How long it takes the spuds to cook depends on their size. They are done when they are tender, and you can easily stick a fork in them.

When the spuds are done, remove them from the heat. Before draining them reserve one-half cup of the cooking liquid and set aside. Pour them into a colander to drain.

Put the spuds back in the pan and let them sit for a few minutes to let the steam escape.

While the spuds are cooking, combine the softened cream cheese and butter in a small bowl. Add two tablespoons of the reserved cooking water, one-fourth teaspoon of salt and pepper, the chives, and stir to combine.

Use the back of a wooden spoon or a potato masher to gently smash the potatoes just until the skin breaks. Do not mash.

Add the cream cheese mixture and combine, being careful not to break up the chunks of potatoes. Add one to two tablespoons of the reserved cooking water and stir to combine.

Taste and add additional salt and pepper if needed. Serve immediately.

Sharon’s tips:

This recipe as written makes two huge portions. Depending on what else you are serving, you can probably get at least three and maybe four servings out of it.

If you need to serve more folks, you can easily double or triple the recipe. This recipe allows you to scale it up or down but it doesn’t change the amount of the reserved cooking water you need to add. You will have to do this manually. It’s better to err on the side of too much water rather than too little.

Make sure your potatoes are roughly the same size so that they will cook evenly. If you have any that are larger than the rest, cut them in two. How long it takes the spuds to cook depends on their size. They are done when they are tender, and you can easily stick a fork in them.

You can substitute any small or baby potatoes for the red potatoes.

Leftovers can be stored tightly covered in the refrigerator for up to four days. To reheat, place them on a microwave-safe dish and heat them in the microwave for a minute or two.

This recipe can be made ahead and reheated covered in a 350-degree oven until it is warmed through. If you are going to make it ahead, add a few more tablespoons of the reserved cooking water to your sauce to make sure the potatoes don’t dry out.

If you make it ahead, you also might want to reserve about a tablespoon of the chopped chives to garnish it with.

What to serve with it:

I served this delicious side dish with Lemon Pepper Salmon, but it would pair equally well with Baked Grouper with Tomatoes and Artichokesor Chicken with Mushrooms and Herbs or even my Easy Southern Style Blue Crab Cakes.

Here is a link to all of my main dish recipes if you need more menu suggestions.

Related recipes:

If you like potatoes as we do, I think you may like these side-dish recipes as well: Old-Fashioned Creamed Potatoes, Easy Southern Potato Salad, Easy Southern Crispy Fried Potatoes, and Southern Candied Sweet Potato Casserole with Pecans.

Here is a link to all of my side dish recipes if you need more inspiration or menu ideas.

★ If you make this recipe, please leave a comment and give it a star rating. I would love to know how you liked it!

Thank you so much for visiting Grits and Pinecones!

📋 Recipe:

*This post was originally published July 26, 2017. It was republished on June 6, 2020, with resized images, expanded directions, and new tips.